Menu

Our Menu: Handcrafted Bagels, Fresh Ingredients, and Flavors You’ll Love

At Whidbey Island Bagel Factory, our menu is a celebration of craftsmanship, creativity, and the timeless tradition of authentic New York–style bagel making. Every item we serve is made with intention: fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and the quality you expect from a bakery dedicated to the art of true boil-and-bake bagels.

Whether you’re craving a simple classic, a hearty breakfast sandwich, or a flavorful specialty bagel topped with house-made cream cheese, our menu offers something for every taste, appetite, and time of day.

1. Handcrafted Bagels — Fresh, Authentic, and Full of Character

Our bagels are the heart of our menu. Each one is:

  • rolled by hand
  • boiled for texture and shine
  • baked fresh daily

We offer a wide selection of both classic and innovative flavors designed to satisfy traditional bagel lovers and adventurous foodies alike.

Signature Bagel Flavors

  • Plain.
  • Everything.
  • Sesame.
  • Sea Salt.
  • Poppy Seed.
  • Multigrain.
  • Pumpernickel.
  • Cinnamon Raisin.
  • Snickerdoodle.
  • Jalapeño Cheddar.
  • Garlic Parmesan.
  • Rosemary Chive.
  • Cranberry Orange Zest.
  • Seasonal & limited-edition flavors.

Each bagel is crafted to deliver the perfect balance of crisp exterior and chewy interior — the hallmark of a true artisan bagel.

2. Cream Cheese Spreads — House-Made, Smooth, and Perfectly Paired

Our signature spreads elevate every bagel with rich texture and bold flavors.
Made fresh and whipped to perfection, they offer the ideal complement to both plain and specialty bagels.

Popular Spread Options

  • Classic Plain Cream Cheese.
  • Herb & Garlic.
  • Chive.
  • Jalapeño.
  • Honey Walnut.
  • Smoked Salmon Cream Cheese.
  • Vegan & dairy-free options.

From savory to sweet, there’s a perfect pairing for every palate.

3. Breakfast Sandwiches — The Perfect Start to Your Day

Our breakfast sandwiches are customer favorites thanks to their hearty portions, fresh ingredients, and bold flavors. Whether you prefer simple and satisfying or fully loaded and indulgent, we have a sandwich to match your morning mood.

Fan Favorites

  • The Classic – egg, cheese, choice of meat.
  • Heart Attack – sausage, bacon, ham, cheese, and egg.
  • Veggie Sunrise – roasted vegetables, egg, melted cheese.
  • Pesto & Egg – house-made pesto, egg, cheese on your favorite bagel.

These sandwiches are prepared to order, ensuring every bite is warm, fresh, and delicious.

4. Lunch Sandwiches — Fresh, Flavorful, and Made With Care

Our lunch menu transforms our artisan bagels into satisfying mid-day meals packed with protein, veggies, herbs, and house sauces.

Popular Lunch Options

  • Lox Bagel – smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, capers.
  • BLT Bagel – crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, creamy mayo.
  • Turkey Club – turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheddar.
  • Reuben Bagel – corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Russian dressing.
  • Veggie Delight – avocado, cucumber, tomato, greens, herb spread.

Each sandwich is thoughtfully crafted to offer balanced flavor and satisfying texture.

5. Soups, Sides & Seasonal Offerings

To enhance your meal, we also offer a rotation of comforting sides and freshly made soups.

  • Daily Soup Specials.
  • Bagel Chips with House Dips.
  • Fresh pastries and baked goods.
  • Seasonal specialties. (pumpkin, cranberry, holiday flavors)

These options add variety and warmth to your dining experience.

6. Beverages — Crafted Drinks to Complete Your Meal

Our drink menu is designed to pair perfectly with our food offerings, featuring everything from bold espresso to refreshing iced beverages.

Beverages Include:

  • Freshly brewed coffee.
  • Espresso drinks (latte, cappuccino, mocha, etc.)
  • Specialty lattes.
  • Herbal teas.
  • Iced coffee & cold brew.
  • Lemonade and seasonal drinks.
  • Hot chocolate & kid-friendly options.

Every drink is served with attention to detail and quality.

7. Vegan, Vegetarian & Dietary-Friendly Options

We believe great food should be accessible to everyone. Our menu includes:

  • vegan spreads.
  • vegetarian sandwiches.
  • dairy-free beverages.
  • meat-free protein options.
  • select items suitable for dietary restrictions.

Ask our team for recommendations — we’re always happy to help.